*
What has the largely left-liberal
The World Tonight (Radio 4) been up to this week?
*
19/4 Presenter
David Eades*
The World Tonight, being the Radio 4 current affairs staple with the most international perspective, is its channel's most Europhile show. For the volcanic ash story, it turned straight to the European Commission, specifically its spokeslady (and former Labour Party official)
Helen Kearns.
*For an Icelandic perspective, it turned to
Alda Sigmundsdottir, introduced by David Eades as
"an Icelandic blogger and journalist". As soon as I hear such a vague description from the BBC I always suspect they will turn out
not to be politically conservative. Alda's blog is
http://www.icelandweatherreport.com/. She also writes for
The Guardian's 'Comment is Free' and
The Huffington Post. So not conservative then.
*The programme then discussed the Lib Dems. Here balance entered, as Iain Martin, the centre-right commentator from The Wall Street Journal & Sunny Hundal, editor of Liberal Conspiracy (and, like Alda, regular contributor to
The Guardian's 'Comment is Free') discussed the wave of Cleggmania that swept the nation, according to the BBC that is.
*
20/4 Presenter
Robin Lustig*
This edition didn't go to the European Commission for more on the volcanic ash story. Instead it went to
Lord Adonis.
*
2. Obama's bank plans were discussed with
"Simon Johnson, former chief economist at the IMF and co-author of a bestselling book on the crisis called '13 Banks'". He voted for Barack Obama.
* *
21/4 Presenter
Robin Lustig *
This was better. The issue of unemployment led, in the wake of news of a rise.
Martin Weale of the think tank
The National Institute for Economic & Social Research. He never strikes me as a partisan for any party, and I've found no evidence that he is either. A real independent expert! Whatever next? Similarly, Jonty Bloom's report from Liverpool featured
Prof Peter Stoney from Liverpool University (who is in favour of the free market) and
Andy Beach from
Unison & John Moores University (who isn't). The debate between Yvette Cooper, Theresa May and David Laws resulted in the following interruption coefficients:
Theresa May -
0.5Yvette Cooper -
0David Laws -
0
Theresa May was the only one Robin interrupted.
*An interesting interview on Brasilia (and other soulless planned cities) between Robin Lustig and
Jonathan Glancey of
'The Guardian' (them again!) followed.
Unfortunately, the programme then returned to the volcanic ash story and its relentless Europhilia, bringing to us the issue of a 'Single European Sky':
"Well the European commission has wanted for many years to introduce a unified air traffic control system for all of the European Union. It's known as the Single European Sky. After all, says the Commission, there's already a single market and a single currency so why not a single sky? I asked the Belgian MEP Dirk Sterckx, who is a member of the European Parliament's transport committee, what exactly would a single sky mean in practice?" Every time an MEP is introduced without any details of party affiliation I just know that he's not going to turn out to be a conservative. Indeed he isn't. Dr Sterckx sits with our Liberal Democrats in the European parliament. He is in favour of a single European sky, of course. What effect has The Great Volcano Crisis had on the argument, wondered Mr Lustig?
"We've seen that the public turns towards Europe", Dirk said. And what of the reluctance of national governments to give up their powers?
"Very illogical" he thinks. (There can be no controversy over the choice of the next guest:
Mike Granatt "used to head the Civil Contingencies Secretariat in the cabinet office". He has served as press officer for both Labour and the Conservatives.)
*For an American perspective on the upcoming second prime ministerial debate, Robin turned to
Styrker Mcguire of
Newsweek, Gavin Esler's liberal best buddy on
'Dateline: London'.
**
22/4 Prime Ministerial Debate special, presenter
Robin Lustig.
**
This was pretty well handled, with a well-balanced panel of pundits, but...
*Before the debate:
*Norman Smith, intriguingly using (but completely mispronouncing) the word
'hyperbole' - a word I often apply to his way of over-painting problems for the Tories (Has he been reading me?!) - kicked things off. He used a fair amount of hyperbole here (such as
"huge" and
"absolutely colossal"), concentrating almost all of his opening remarks on the pressures facing David Cameron
("There is massive pressure on him". Even if Clegg were only to do OK, it would be "a disastrous outcome" for the Tories. "So enormous pressure tonight").
After the debate:
*I've already reviewed Norman's instant reaction/spin in a previous post.
*
He returned after the 10 0'clock news to spin again. He conceded that both Cameron and Brown had done
"considerably better" this week, but was soon back to his old ways, saying again that Clegg
"emerged as the winner" (no ifs, no buts). Can you guess which clip he first chose to illustrate the debate? Clegg's atrocious attack on the
"nutters, anti-Semites, people who deny climate change exists, homophobes" who sit alongside the Conservatives in the Eurolandic parliament. He then said
"actually Gordon Brown had a number of good lines". There was no such praise for David Cameron though. Who's surprised?
*
Ritula Shah was out with the public, or more precisely with students from Reading University. A
"completely unscientific poll" in the students' union bar saw a landslide for Clegg. Then four of the students were gathered. One, an American, remained undecided, liked Clegg's foreign policy but said that, looked on objectively, Cameron probably won. The second likes the Lib Dems but said that Brown is
"someone" he
"supports quite strongly". The third also said she admires Brown. The fourth is president of the university's Labour Society! So
'dunno, Brown, Brown and Brown'. How very representative!!
Following
Peter Kellner of
YouGov and
Rory Cellan-Jones on Twitter, blogs, facebook came
"a satirist's eye". The satirist Robin talked to was
Alistair Beaton. Wikipedia describes him as
"a Scottish left wing political satirist". Robin forgot to tell us that
"at one point in his career he was also a speechwriter for Gordon Brown." That said, he was very even-handed in his barbs. He won't be writing speeches for Brown after this!!
23/4 Presenter
Ritula Shah*This edition began with Greece and presented two sides of the New Greco-German War. For the German view we had
Michael Gahler,
"an MEP from Mrs Merkel's party". (Ah, he's been labelled so we know
he's a conservative!) For the Greek side we got
Yanis Varoufakis, professor of economics, university of Athens, who criticised German delays. He worked here in England for some time before, as his webpage puts it, he
"escaped Maggie's England for Sydney, Australia".
This may suggest where he comes from politically!!
*Mark Simpson then reported from Northern Ireland on the debate over there, talking to justice minister
David Ford from the Alliance Party. Some 80's music was then played, before Mark said
"the theme was from the 1980s, and so was the line of questioning for Sinn Fein's Gerry Adams. Was he an IRA leader during the Troubles? He repeated that he wasn't and said it was pointless even talking about it". Sir Reg Empey,
Peter Robinson and
Margaret Ritchie followed, with the
"hardline" (as Mr Simpson put it, using his only label)
Jim Allister of the TUV adding a comment towards the end.
*Finally, the 0.2% rise in GDP was described by Ritula as
"slightly less than expected". "
Slightly?" Is a difference of 0.2% in terms of growth figures "
slight"?
