BBC Complaints: The link you need!

Monday, 1 February 2010

JANUARY'S I.C.s - INTRODUCTION AND FULL LIST

*
A new month means another list of interruption coefficients.
*
286 interviews have occured throughout January. As always, this covers every edition of:
*
Today
The Daily Politics
The World At One
PM
The World Tonight
Newsnight
The Andrew Marr Show
Broadcasting House
The Politics Show
The World This Weekend
The Politics Show: Scotland
Dragon's Eye
The Record: Europe
Westminster Hour

*
Just as a reminder - Interruption Coefficients (I.C.s) are calculated by dividing the number of interruptions by the length of the interview. The higher the I.C. the tougher the interview (as a rule). I.C.s of 0 have contained no interruptions! Interruptions are only classed as interruptions if they stop or significantly alter the speaker's flow. Muttered 'wells' and the like are classed as 'abortive interruptions' and are not counted. Those that share an I.C., say of 0.8, are sub-ranked according to a hidden (inferior) measure called the Questions Coefficient, which is calculated by dividing thee number of questions by the length of the interview. The more questions there are, the likelier the interviewer is holding the reins in an interview. That means that everything is ranked just where it should be!
*
As usual I will begin with the full list (with apologies as ever for the lack of punctuation!!):
*
*
Date, Interviewer, Interviewee, Party, I.C.
*
21/01 Andrew Neil Philip Hammond Conservative 3.3
*
13/01 Jeremy Paxman Mike O'Brien Labour 3.2
25/01 Jeremy Paxman Philip Hammond Conservative 3.2
*
12/01 Andrew Neil Arlene Foster DUP 3.1
04/01 Jeremy Paxman Philip Hammond Conservative 3.1
*
20/01 Jeremy Paxman Edward Timpson Conservative 3
*
21/01 Gavin Esler Lord Pearson UKIP 2.8
*
12/01 Andrew Neil Alex Maskey Sinn Fein 2.5
05/01 Jo Coburn Grant Shapps Conservative 2.5
*
31/01 Shirin Wheeler Lord Dartmouth UKIP 2.4
*
07/01 Andrew Neil Tony McNulty Labour 2.3
20/01 John Humphrys David Willetts Conservative 2.3
*
04/01 Jeremy Paxman Liam Byrne Labour 2.1
21/01 Andrew Neil Ed Davey Lib Dem 2.1
25/01 Andrew Neil Sarah McCarthy-Fry Labour 2.1
*
12/01 Jeremy Paxman Lord Falconer Labour 2
*
25/01 Andrew Neil Theresa May Conservative 1.8
*
22/01 Jo Coburn Jeremy Brier Conservative 1.7
31/01 Gary Robertson John Swinney SNP 1.7
06/01 Jeremy Paxman Peter Mandelson Labour 1.7
04/01 Eddie Mair Andrew Lansley Conservative 1.7
06/01 Justin Webb Justine Greening Conservative 1.7
*
06/01 Andrew Neil Chris Bryant Labour 1.6
17/01 Jon Sopel Ed Balls Labour 1.6
26/01 Ed Stourton Tim Lewis Conservative 1.6
22/01 Jo Coburn Rachel Reeves Labour 1.6
25/01 Sarah Montague Sammy Wilson DUP 1.6
*
18/01 Andrew Neil Mark Lancaster Conservative 1.5
07/01 James Naughtie Eric Joyce Labour 1.5
26/01 Jeremy Paxman Alistair Darling Labour 1.5
05/01 Jo Coburn Danny Alexander Lib Dem 1.5
13/01 Andrew Neil Peter Hain Labour 1.5
31/01 Sophie Raworth Harriet Harman Labour 1.5
05/01 Justin Webb Nick Clegg Lib Dem 1.5
20/01 John Humphrys David Laws Lib Dem 1.5
06/01 Justin Webb John Hutton Labour 1.5
*
27/01 Jo Coburn Michael Heseltine Conservative 1.4
27/01 Ed Stourton Philip Hammond Conservative 1.4
15/01 Jo Coburn Baroness Neville-Jones Conservative 1.4
11/01 Andrew Neil Danny Alexander Lib Dem 1.4
09/01 Andrew Marr David Cameron Conservative 1.4
17/01 Andrew Marr Nick Clegg Lib Dem 1.4
*
26/01 Felicity Evans Philip Hammond Conservative 1.3
08/01 Jo Coburn Joanne Cash Conservative 1.3
20/01 Jeremy Paxman Meg Munn Labour 1.3
20/01 Andrew Neil John Denham Labour 1.3
22/01 Justin Webb George Osborne Conservative 1.3
25/01 Jeremy Paxman Vince Cable Lib Dem 1.3
12/01 Jo Coburn Alex Salmond SNP 1.3
14/01 Emily Maitlis George Osborne Conservative 1.3
24/01 Glenn Campbell Anne McLaughlin SNP 1.3
05/01 James Naughtie Nick Herbert Conservative 1.3
10/01 Carolyn Quinn Ed Vaizey Conservative 1.3
20/01 John Humphrys Ed Balls Labour 1.3
22/01 James Naughtie Rob Hayward Conservative 1.3
27/01 Ed Stourton Denis MacShane Labour 1.3
20/01 Jeremy Paxman Philip Hammond Conservative 1.3
*
27/01 Andrew Neil Eric Pickles Conservative 1.2
10/01 Carolyn Quinn Emily Thornberry Labour 1.2
06/01 Andrew Neil Lord Strathclyde Conservative 1.2
31/01 Jon Sopel David Cameron Conservative 1.2
11/01 Justin Webb Boris Johnson Conservative 1.2
21/01 Ed Stourton David Liddington Conservative 1.2
18/01 Evan Davis Michael Gove Conservative 1.2
25/01 Jeremy Paxman Lord Myners Labour 1.2
*
17/01 Jon Sopel Nigel Farage UKIP 1.1
25/01 Andrew Neil Chris Huhne Lib Dem 1.1
28/01 Andrew Neil John Hutton Labour 1.1
20/01 Andrew Neil Lord Tebbit Conservative 1.1
07/01 Evan Davis David Cameron Conservative 1.1
06/01 Jo Coburn Chris Bryant Labour 1.1
08/01 Shaun Ley Ed Miliband Labour 1.1
26/01 Ed Stourton Alistair Darling Labour 1.1
*
28/01 Andrew Neil Liam Fox Lib Dem 1
27/01 Jo Coburn Phil Woolas Labour 1
24/01 Jon Sopel Chris Grayling Conservative 1
28/01 Shelagh Fogarty John Hutton Labour 1
18/01 Andrew Neil Joan Walley Labour 1
24/01 Andrew Marr David Miliband Labour 1
26/01 Andrew Neil Liam Byrne Labour 1
31/01 Sophie Raworth George Osborne Labour 1
15/01 Brian Hanrahan Andrew Mitchell Conservative 1
19/01 Evan Davis Alan Johnson Labour 1
22/01 Gavin Esler Ed Balls Labour 1
20/01 Jo Coburn John Denham Labour 1
*
06/01 Eddie Mair Ed Miliband Labour 0.9
06/01 Jeremy Paxman Geoff Hoon Labour 0.9
05/01 Jo Coburn Stephen Timms Labour 0.9
26/01 Andrew Neil Vince Cable Lib Dem 0.9
13/01 Jo Coburn Peter Hain Labour 0.9
19/01 Andrew Neil Chris Grayling Conservative 0.9
24/01 Jon Sopel Harriet Harman Labour 0.9
13/01 Martha Kearney John Healey Labour 0.9
27/01 Andrew Neil Phil Woolas Labour 0.9
01/01 Felicity Evans Mike Foster Labour 0.9
19/01 James Naughtie John Reid Labour 0.9
22/01 Ed Stourton Ed Balls Labour 0.9
24/01 Norman Smith Lord Pearson UKIP 0.9
11/01 Jeremy Paxman Roy Hattersley Labour 0.9
04/01 Jeremy Paxman Khalid Mahmood Labour 0.9
*
06/01 Robin Lustig Geraldine Smith Labour 0.8
06/01 Robin Lustig Ben Bradshaw Labour 0.8
14/01 Eddie Mair John Mann Labour 0.8
20/01 Jo Coburn Lord Tebbit Conservative 0.8
22/01 Ed Stourton Lord Myners Labour 0.8
10/01 Shaun Ley David Trimble Conservative & Unionist 0.8
24/01 Glenn Campbell Fiona Hyslop SNP 0.8
03/01 Andrew Marr Gordon Brown Labour 0.8
15/01 John Humphrys Baroness Neville-Jones Conservative 0.8
*
08/01 Jo Coburn Karen Jennings Labour 0.7
08/01 Jo Coburn Ken Livingstone Labour 0.7
11/01 Jeremy Paxman John Prescott Labour 0.7
28/01 Eddie Mair Douglas Alexander Labour 0.7
14/01 Andrew Neil Don Foster Lib Dem 0.7
25/01 John Humphrys Lord Fowler Conservative 0.7
24/01 Andrew Marr Rory Stewart Conservative 0.7
18/01 Jeremy Paxman Tim Loughton Conservative 0.7
27/01 Eddie Mair Clare Short Ind Labour 0.7
08/01 Shaun Ley Mitchell McLaughlin Sinn Fein 0.7
12/01 Jo Coburn Margaret Beckett Labour 0.7
03/01 Carolyn Quinn Panjit Dhanda Labour 0.7
06/01 Martha Kearney David Laws Lib Dem 0.7
*
31/01 Adrian Masters Cheryl Gillan Conservative 0.6
08/01 Eddie Mair Alisdair McDonnell SDLP 0.6
13/01 Andrew Neil Nigel Farage UKIP 0.6
19/01 James Naughtie Chris Grayling Conservative 0.6
06/01 Martha Kearney Chris Bryant Labour 0.6
11/01 Eddie Mair Mitchell McLaughlin Sinn Fein 0.6
25/01 Sarah Montague Gerry Kelly Sinn Fein 0.6
07/01 James Naughtie Shaun Woodward Labour 0.6
09/01 James Naughtie Michael Portillo Conservative 0.6
27/01 Justin Webb Harriet Harman Labour 0.6
25/01 Felicity Evans Vince Cable Lib Dem 0.6
27/01 Sarah Montague Theresa May Conservative 0.6
27/01 Andrew Neil Michael Heseltine Conservative 0.6
17/01 Glenn Campbell Shona Robison SNP 0.6
28/01 Gavin Esler Denis MacShane Labour 0.6
29/01 Brian Hanrahan Sir Ming Campbell Lib Dem 0.6
31/01 Carolyn Quinn Caroline Lucas Green 0.6
*
19/01 Andrew Neil Ken Livingstone Labour 0.5
31/01 Sophie Raworth Clare Short Ind Labour 0.5
15/01 James Naughtie Vince Cable Lib Dem 0.5
21/01 John Humphrys Kim Howells Labour 0.5
01/01 Eddie Mair Mark Oaten Lib Dem 0.5
27/01 Ed Stourton John Denham Labour 0.5
06/01 Martha Kearney Patricia Hewitt Labour 0.5
31/01 Jon Sopel Peter Mandelson Labour 0.5
04/01 Martha Kearney Rachael Reeves Labour 0.5
21/01 Sarah Montague Tom Watson Labour 0.5
26/01 John Humphrys Michael Cashman Labour 0.5
11/01 Martha Kearney David Miliband Labour 0.5
08/01 Robin Lustig Jim Allister TUV 0.5
27/01 Justin Webb David Laws Lib Dem 0.5
13/01 Evan Davis Andrew Lansley Conservative 0.5
*
24/01 Felicity Evans Carwyn Jones Labour 0.4
25/01 Eddie Mair Lord Myners Labour 0.4
11/01 Jeremy Paxman Shaun Woodward Labour 0.4
04/01 Martha Kearney Rory Stewart Conservative 0.4
12/01 Eddie Mair Patrick Mercer Conservative 0.4
13/01 Jeremy Paxman Vince Cable Lib Dem 0.4
17/01 Glenn Campbell Jeremy Purvis Lib Dem 0.4
28/01 Robin Lustig Chris Bryant Labour 0.4
13/01 Jo Coburn Charles Kennedy Lib Dem 0.4
23/01 Ritula Shah Patrick Mercer Conservative 0.4
18/01 Evan Davis Lord Myners Labour 0.4
04/01 Justin Webb Brian Paddick Lib Dem 0.4
05/01 Ritula Shah Dick Taverne Lib Dem 0.4
06/01 Martha Kearney Eric Pickles Conservative 0.4
07/11 Robin Lustig Lord Hunt Labour 0.4
09/01 Sarah Montague Glenys Kinnock Labour 0.4
17/01 Shirin Wheeler Glenis Willmott Labour 0.4
19/01 Ritula Shah Sir Ming Campbell Lib Dem 0.4
28/01 James Naughtie Gordon Brown Labour 0.4
29/01 Gavin Esler Sir Ming Campbell Lib Dem 0.4
05/01 James Naughtie Hilary Benn Labour 0.4
22/01 James Naughtie Lord Philip Gould Labour 0.4
10/01 Carolyn Quinn Jeremy Browne Lib Dem 0.4
31/01 Shirin Wheeler Richard Howitt Labour 0.4
*
29/01 Brian Hanrahan Liam Fox Conservative 0.3
24/01 Glenn Campbell Ann McKechin Labour 0.3
19/01 Martha Kearney Geoffrey Robinson Labour 0.3
26/01 Felicity Evans Lord Mandelson Labour 0.3
12/01 Evan Davis Bernard Jenkin Conservative 0.3
28/01 Gavin Esler David Miliband Labour 0.3
03/01 Andrew Marr Michael Portillo Conservative 0.3
08/01 Sarah Montague Bridget Prentice Labour 0.3
11/01 James Naughtie Anne Begg Labour 0.3
24/01 Shirin Wheeler Claude Moraes Labour 0.3
29/01 Gavin Esler Margaret Beckett Labour 0.3
04/01 Justin Webb Ben Wallace Conservative 0.3
11/01 Robin Lustig Alex Massey Sinn Fein 0.3
27/01 Eddie Mair Clive Soley Labour 0.3
03/01 Carolyn Quinn Ed Vaizey Conservative 0.3
26/01 Sarah Montague Lord Joffe Labour 0.3
13/01 Evan Davis Ming Campell Lib Dem 0.3
17/01 Shirin Wheeler Geoffrey Van Orden Conservative 0.3
21/01 Eddie Mair Denis MacShane Labour 0.3
30/01 James Naughtie Chris Huhne Lib Dem 0.3
02/01 Sarah Montague Des Browne Labour 0.3
29/01 Brian Hanrahan Lord Falconer Labour 0.3
*
11/01 Eddie Mair Gregory Campbell DUP 0.2
21/01 John Humphrys Lord Wallace Lib Dem 0.2
01/01 Shaun Ley Louise Ellman Labour 0.2
31/01 Carolyn Quinn Tom Harris Labour 0.2
31/01 Carolyn Quinn Lynne Featherstone Lib Dem 0.2
17/01 Norman Smith Tom Harris Labour 0.2
24/01 Norman Smith Charles Walker Conservative 0.2
29/01 Eddie Mair Margaret Beckett Labour 0.2
03/01 Carolyn Quinn Patrick Cormack Conservative 0.2
08/01 Sarah Montague Hilary Benn Labour 0.2
11/01 James Naughtie Alex Massey Sinn Fein 0.2
11/01 James Naughtie Nick Clegg Lib Dem 0.2
17/01 Norman Smith Mark Field Conservative 0.2
30/01 Evan Davis Alistair Darling Labour 0.2
11/01 James Naughtie Ed Balls Labour 0.2
*
09/01 Sarah Montague Shaun Woodward Labour 0.1
24/01 Norman Smith Jeremy Browne Lib Dem 0.1
*
22/01 Ed Stourton Vince Cable Lib Dem 0
31/01 Shirin Wheeler Mary Honeyball Labour 0
11/01 Robin Lustig Barry Sheerman Labour 0
04/01 Martha Kearney James Arbuthnot Conservative 0
09/01 Sarah Montague Dave Sparks Labour 0
25/01 Eddie Mair
David Ford Alliance 0
07/01 Evan Davis David Sparks Labour 0
08/01 Sarah Montague Kevin Barron Labour 0
05/01 Martha Kearney Greg Clark Conservative 0
05/01 Martha Kearney Geoffrey Robinson Labour 0
07/01 Martha Kearney John Knight Labour 0
16/01 Felicity Evans Tony Benn Labour 0
17/01 Shirin Wheeler Jean Lambert Green 0
25/01 Sarah Montague Douglas Alexander Labour 0
07/01 Shelagh Fogarty Nadine Dorries Conservative 0
11/01 Martha Kearney Jeffrey Donaldson DUP 0
13/01 Martha Kearney Douglas Alexander Labour 0
20/01 Martha Kearney Simon Hughes Lib Dem 0
31/01 Shirin Wheeler Kay Swinburne Conservative 0
04/01 Martha Kearney Karen Gillard Lib Dem 0
12/01 Martha Kearney Lord Carlisle Lib Dem 0
13/01 Martha Kearney Caroline Spelman Conservative 0
22/01 James Naughtie Phil Woolas Labour 0
10/01 Shaun Ley Jim Allister TUV 0
17/01 Glenn Campbell Lord Hunt Labour 0
20/01 Martha Kearney Theresa May Conservative 0
21/01 Eddie Mair Ed Davey Lib Dem 0
30/01 Carolyn Quinn Chris Grayling Conservative 0
04/01 Ritula Shah Rory Stewart Conservative 0
06/01 Jo Coburn Lord Strathclyde Conservative 0
06/01 Martha Kearney John McFall Labour 0
07/11 Robin Lustig Gareth Thomas Labour 0
08/01 Shaun Ley David Ford Alliance 0
14/01 Martha Kearney Douglas Alexander Labour 0
16/01 Felicity Evans Carl Minns Lib Dem 0
21/01 Shelagh Fogarty Peter Kilfoyle Labour 0
27/01 Robin Lustig Sir Alan Beith Lib Dem 0
01/01 Carolyn Quinn Keith Vaz Labour 0
14/01 Sarah Montague John Denham Labour 0
14/01 John Humphrys Alan Beith Lib Dem 0
15/01 Felicity Evans Douglas Alexander Labour 0
17/01 Glenn Campbell Richard Simpson Labour 0
17/01 Glenn Campbell Derek Brownlee Conservative 0
18/01 Martha Kearney Cathy Ashton Labour 0
29/01 Eddie Mair Chris Mullin Labour 0
01/01 Norman Smith Tony Benn Labour 0
05/01 Martha Kearney Sally Keeble Labour 0
12/01 Jeremy Paxman Ming Campbell Lib Dem 0
14/01 John Humphrys Douglas Alexander Labour 0
20/01 Martha Kearney Jim Knight Labour 0
22/01 Ed Stourton Tim Lawton Conservative 0
24/01 Glenn Campbell Margo MacDonald Independent 0
27/01 Ed Stourton Jeremy Browne Lib Dem 0
31/01 Jonny Dymond Ed Miliband Labour 0
03/01 Paddy O'Connell Kim Howell Labour 0
04/01 Evan Davis Malcolm Rifkind Conservative 0
09/01 Ritula Shah Sir Patrick Cormack Conservative 0
12/01 Eddie Mair Sally Keeble Labour 0
12/01 Martha Kearney Keith Vaz Labour 0
25/01 Felicity Evans Alex Atwood SDLP 0
20/01 Sarah Montague Nicola Sturgeon SNP 0
28/01 Evan Davis David Blunkett Labour 0
13/01 Martha Kearney Danny Alexander Lib Dem 0
02/01 Justin Webb John Major Conservative 0
17/01 Jon Sopel Salma Yaqoob Respect 0
12/01 Martha Kearney Lord Falconer Labour 0
24/01 Shirin Wheeler Andrew Duff Lib Dem 0
28/01 Justin Webb Claude Moraes Labour 0
13/01 Andrew Neil Charles Kennedy Lib Dem 0

3 comments:

  1. Fantastic work, Craig. Not just the numbers, but the colours tell a story too.
    After "unintentional interruptions", we also have "abortive interruptions ". Love it.
    You have the makings of a PhD here ,
    except almost no British University would accept it !

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Grant.
    Yes, the colours give even a casual reader (who has to scroll all the way past this long post!) a good sense of the lay of the land, with lots of blue at the very lot and acres and acres of red and orange down at the bottom.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Even with a 5-10% recording error, the evidence is overwhelming !

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.